Julien's Auctions · Sale 428 · Lot 1066
ANNE V. COATES: "THE ELEPHANT MAN" ORIGINAL LINED SCRIPT (WITH DVD)
A production used original lined shooting script for the classic David Lynch film The Elephant Man (Brooksfilms, 1980) by Christopher De Vore, Eric Bergren, and Lynch, from the estate of editor Anne V. Coates, who received an Academy Award nomination for her work on the film.
The script is labelled "REVISED," and the date "June 26, 1979" is crossed out and replaced with "1 August" in pen. The cameras and angles used to shoot each scene are demarcated by drawn lines in the script that run vertically through each described shot. When multiple cameras are used to film a scene, multiple lines run parallel to each other in the script. The script is further annotated, including areas in which dialogue has been crossed out or added, likely by script supervisor Jack H. Degelia upon Lynch's request.
Coates initially did not want to work on the film because she feared that Lynch, known for the disturbing Eraserhead (American Film Institute, 1977), would depict John Merrick aka "the elephant man" as grotesque and horrific. Her daughter, Emma E. Hickox, who was very enthusiastic about the project, persuaded to her that, through editing, Coates could help emphasize the film's focus on Merrick's perspective, and humanize him.
When Coates read the film's screenplay, she knew that her daughter was right, and that her vision aligned with the film's values. At a Manhattan Edit Workshop event titled "Sight, Sound, and Story," Coates said:
"I read the script and I was in tears, and I thought I really must do this film."
During production, Coates found herself in the middle of a disagreement between David Lynch and the film's executive producer, Mel Brooks, about the famous scene in which Dr. Frederick Treves (Anthony Hopkins), and the audience, meet John Merrick (John Hurt).
In the script, Merrick's face is revealed without a hood for the first time in this scene. Brooks felt the audience shouldn't see his face until a later scene, after Dr. Treves has taken him into his home and the audience has come to know him. In the scene Brooks preferred for the revelation, the doctor's maid walks in on Merrick's room and reacts with terror, at which point the audience, knowing that he's not frightening, would see what she sees. He asked Lynch to shoot two versions of Treves's introduction to Merrick, one where his face would be revealed, another where it would be hidden.
At the "Sight, Sound, and Story" event, Coates said:
"I presumed we were going to shoot it both ways. But David wanted to see it when Treves first saw it and a tear came down his face, and so he didn't shoot it both ways. And Mel Brooks was really pretty annoyed about that. Because [David] was insisting on us doing it the other way 'round. And so we had to take out, or cut 'round the scene. But I managed to get 'round it so that we were able to not see the elephant man until the nurse sees him. Mel was no fool. He knew what he was doing."
Lynch's preferred version of Dr. Treves's introduction to Merrick appears in this version of the script. The lines drawn throughout the scene, demarcating different camera angles, suggest the different footage that Coates had to work with in "working 'round" the scene as shot to fulfill Brooks's wishes.
In a 2000 interview at FilmSound.org, Coates told fellow editor Walter Murch that working on The Elephant Man was "one of the best decisions of my life."
This lot includes a DVD of the film.
Dimensions: 13.75 x 9.25 x 1 inches
Provenance
From The Estate of Anne V. Coates








